Leading through Suffering - 1 Peter 5:1-7
Introduction
The Elders - 5:1-4
How do elders shepherd and oversee?
Not under compulsion, but willingly.
Not for dishonest gain, but with eagerness.
Not lording it over, but being examples.
The Young People - 5:5a
It is probably because the younger people were generally those who would most need a reminder to be submissive to authority within the church (and there is no need to restrict this to ‘young men’, NIV, or ‘younger men’, NASB, since the masculine plural noun would be used to refer to a mixed group of men and women as well). This would not imply that the others were free to rebel against the elders, but quite the opposite: if those who are likely to be most independent-minded and even at times rebellious against church leaders are commanded to be subject to the elders, then it follows that certainly everyone else must be subject to the elders as well.
The younger in particular, then, should submit (hypotagēte) to the leadership of the elders. We have seen elsewhere that Peter understood submission as the responsibility of believers to those in positions of authority (cf. 2:13, 18; 3:1, 5). The purpose is not to encourage obedience no matter what leaders might say, for if leaders give counsel that contravenes God’s moral standards or violates the gospel, then they should not be followed. Nor is the verse suggesting that leaders are exempt from accountability before the congregation. We have already observed that elders are admonished not to use their authority as dictatorial rulers but are to serve those under their charge. Conversely, those who are under leadership should be inclined to follow and submit to their leaders. They should not be resisting the initiatives of leaders and complaining about the direction of the church.