Sermon Tone Analysis

The NET Bible  -  Genesis 3:16

3:16 - To the woman he said,

“I will greatly increase46 your labor pains;47

with pain you will give birth to children.

You will want to control your husband,48

but he will dominate49 you.”

48*tn* /Heb/ “and toward your husband [will be] your desire.”

The nominal sentence does not have a verb; a future verb must be supplied, because the focus of the oracle is on the future struggle.

The precise meaning of the noun hq~*WvT= (T=vWq~*h, “desire”) is debated.

Many interpreters conclude that it refers to sexual desire here, because the subject of the passage is the relationship between a wife and her husband, and because the word is used in a romantic sense in Song 7:11 HT (7:10 ET).

However, this interpretation makes little sense in Gen 3:16.

First, it does not fit well with the assertion “he will dominate you.”

Second, it implies that sexual desire was not part of the original creation, even though the man and the woman were told to multiply.

And third, it ignores the usage of the word in Gen 4:7 where it refers to sin’s desire to control and dominate Cain.

(Even in Song of Songs it carries the basic idea of “control,” for it describes the young man’s desire to “have his way sexually” with the young woman.)

In Gen 3:16 the Lord announces a struggle, a conflict between the man and the woman.

She will desire to control him, but he will dominate her instead.

This interpretation also fits the tone of the passage, which is a judgment oracle.

See further Susan T. Foh, “What is the Woman’s Desire?” /WTJ/ 37 (1975): 376-83.

\\ 49*tn* The Hebrew verb lvm (m~*v~*l) means “to rule over,” but in a way that emphasizes powerful control, domination, or mastery.

This also is part of the baser human nature.

The translation assumes the imperfect verb form has an objective~/indicative sense here.

Another option is to understand it as having a modal, desiderative nuance, “but he will want to dominate you.”

In this case, the Lord simply announces the struggle without indicating who will emerge victorious.