Two Sons
INTRO
Nonetheless, the death of Bathsheba’s new son leaves today’s readers with one of the most difficult aspects of Old Testament faith. Why is David forgiven while the innocent newborn has to die? The answer lies in the Bible’s distinction between punishment and consequence. The child’s death is a result of David’s sin, but this is not the same as punishment. It is a fundamental principle of life that God may forgive and cleanse us of all wrongdoing, but the consequences of our sin may, and in fact often, remain. The innocent suffer for crimes committed by someone else, but such suffering is not punishment for those crimes. A crack baby may die soon after birth because the mother used crack during pregnancy. The child dies; the mother lives. The child’s death is not the punishment but the consequences of the mother’s sin. Her punishment will take a different form.
