Suffer Well
Don’t go Paul!
First, the phrase through the Spirit is inconclusive; it merely means that someone spoke as from a spiritual gift of prophecy. As Paul notes in 1 Corinthians 14:29, however, not every manifestation of the gift of prophecy is legitimate. Whether it was legitimate in this instance must be determined by other factors.
Second, Paul lived a life sensitive to the Spirit’s leading. When forbidden by the Spirit to preach in certain regions, Paul did not disobey (Acts 16:6–7). When led by the Spirit to minister in Macedonia, Paul immediately obeyed (Acts 16:9–10). That long-term pattern of obedience makes it unlikely that he was disobedient in this matter.
Third, the Holy Spirit had never before prohibited Paul from going to Jerusalem. According to Acts 20:22–23, He warned Paul repeatedly of what would happen to him when he got there but did not tell him not to go.
Fourth, Paul described his mission to Jerusalem as “the ministry which I received from the Lord Jesus” (Acts 20:24). How could the Holy Spirit forbid Paul from doing what the Lord Jesus Christ had commanded him to? Further, Acts 19:21 records that “Paul purposed in the spirit to go to Jerusalem,” while in Acts 20:22 the apostle describes himself as “bound in spirit … on my way to Jerusalem.” He was compelled in his innermost being by the Holy Spirit to undertake this mission.
Finally, the Scriptures nowhere suggest that Paul sinned by going to Jerusalem. After he got there he declared, “I have lived my life with a perfectly good conscience before God up to this day” (Acts 23:1; cf. 24:16). It is difficult to see how he could have said that if he had just flagrantly sinned against God.