The Oneness
Why Polytheism?
1. Is it possible for anything to be purely one, without being many in some way?
2. How is God’s oneness related to his sovereignty, his lordship?
3. How does the oneness of God tell you to live?
Likewise, when we think of our achievements from a cosmic perspective, it is very difficult to isolate what we do from what has been done for us. We are alive because of a vast causal nexus above and below us. The same is true of our abilities, and, therefore, our achievements. Beethoven could write symphonies because he came from a vast family tree, and because all his ancestors breathed the earth’s air and received food and drink from its seeds, rain, and sunshine. He had the right genes, education, and experience. At any moment of his life, he might have been destroyed by a falling tree or a tiny virus. Or one of his ancestors might have been destroyed, preventing Beethoven’s family line from bringing him to life. He wrote the symphonies; nobody else did, and nobody can take those away from him. But his achievements are dependent on something vastly larger than he.
But how is it possible for the Greatness to also be a Oneness? The world is a place of astonishing complexity, of a vast number of things, events, processes, and causal chains. There is a huge complex of relationships in this world. Beethoven’s genetic inheritance is something different from his breakfast. But his breakfast becomes Beethoven, and his genetic inheritance determines what his breakfast later becomes. Genetics and food interact with one another and with many other things to produce the next chapters in Beethoven’s story. Imagine the complex of factors that must be united to tell the world’s story. Polytheism cannot tell that story. It must neatly separate all the factors, so as to ascribe one event to one god and another to another, so that no god is deprived of his proper honor. The one-and-many world must result from one overarching intelligence that provides not only causes, but interrelations and integrations.
