6 Stream - 4 Spaces (Compassion & Conviction)

Justice & Civic Formation  •  Sermon  •  Submitted   •  Presented
0 ratings
· 6 views
Notes
Transcript

Framework: Compassion & Conviction

The AND Campaign calls Christians to resist false choices:

Love or truth
justice or righteousness,
compassion or conviction,
concern for personal morality or concern for social structures.

Keller

Truth without love is harshness. Love without truth is sentimentality.
Balance: Keller points to the gospel model—combining radical truthfulness about God’s righteousness & humanity’s flaws with unconditional commitment and grace, which gives people the safety to face themselves and grow.

The right visualization

Not a scale to balance
Lemonade (Lemon and Sugar)

A Robust Christian Public Witness Requires a Robust Christian Spirituality

We cannot sustain a robust Christian public witness without cultivating a robust Christian spirituality.

The Compassion & Conviction Framework is about more than just calling balls or strikes…thinking rightly about politics and civic culture.
There is a deeper question beneath this challenge: What kind of people must we become to sustain this kind of witness?

Our public witness is an expression of our Christian discipleship. Therefore, the quality of our public witness will be shaped by the quality of our spiritual formation.

Our politics will eventually expose the limits of our spirituality.

We may hold all the right positions while lacking the virtues necessary to pursue them faithfully.
We can be right on an issue and wrong in our disposition.
We can defend biblical truth while being unloving, or demonstrate patience and kindness while avoiding difficult moral truths.

The challenge is not simply to develop better political arguments. It is to become the kind of people who can consistently embody the truths we profess.

We cannot have a politics that consistently outpaces the kind of people we are becoming.

Richard Foster's Streams of Living Water offers a useful framework for thinking about the breadth of Christian spirituality.

Foster identifies six historic streams of Christian faith and practice.

They developed different emphases in different communities and moments of church history.
Each preserves something important about what it means to follow Jesus.

His central image is a river fed by multiple streams.

The church is impoverished when these streams become isolated from one another.
It is enriched when their distinctive contributions come together in a more complete vision of life in Christ.

This is not an endorsement of every theological claim or practice associated with these traditions. Nor are these six categories an exhaustive account of Christian spirituality. They are a useful framework for noticing dimensions of discipleship we might otherwise neglect.

The Six Streams of Christian Spirituality

Stream 1: The Contemplative Tradition — The Prayer-Filled Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE WE CULTIVATING INTIMACY WITH GOD?
Central emphasis: A life of communion with God through prayer, meditation, silence, solitude, and attentiveness to God's presence.
The contemplative tradition reminds us that Christianity is fundamentally relational. We are not merely called to believe things about God or do things for God. We are invited to know God.
A prayer-filled life cultivates spiritual attentiveness. We become more sensitive to God's presence, God's purposes, and our own motivations.
Contemplation is not necessarily withdrawal from the world. Deep communion with God can produce deeper love for the world.
Examples from Foster:
- Anthony the Great (251–356). Often called Anthony of the Desert, he withdrew into the Egyptian wilderness to pursue a life of prayer, spiritual discipline, and devotion to God. Foster uses him as an early example of contemplative spirituality.
- Frank Laubach (1884–1970). A missionary who sought to cultivate an ongoing awareness of God's presence. His prayer life helped inspire a global literacy movement. His example demonstrates that prayer and active service need not be competitors.
Connection to public witness:
Political engagement invites constant reaction. There is always another controversy, threat, outrage, or opportunity.
Contemplative spirituality helps us resist the temptation to become reactionary people.
If we cannot be still before God, how will we remain spiritually grounded in the storms of public life?

Stream 2: The Holiness Tradition — The Virtuous Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE WE BECOMING PEOPLE OF CHRISTLIKE CHARACTER?
Central emphasis: The transformation of the human heart and the cultivation of habits and virtues consistent with the character of Jesus.
Holiness is more than avoiding particular sins. It is the positive development of a character shaped by God's grace.
Spiritual practices train us to respond faithfully when circumstances become difficult.
The goal is not merely knowing the right thing but becoming the kind of person who actually does the right thing.
Examples from Foster:
- Phoebe Palmer (1807–1874). A major figure in the Wesleyan Holiness movement who emphasized consecration, practical holiness, and a life devoted to God.
- Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906–1945). His understanding of costly discipleship demanded obedience to Christ even when it placed him in opposition to the Nazi regime. Foster points to his Christ-centered discipleship and the courage it produced.
Connection to public witness:
The public square tests our character, especially when the stakes are high.
We need Christians who are not simply committed to honesty but who have become honest people; not merely committed to courage but who have developed courageous character.
This matters because political environments often reward the very behaviors that Christian discipleship is supposed to reform: pride, dishonesty, resentment, contempt, and the pursuit of power for its own sake.

Stream 3: The Charismatic Tradition — The Spirit-Empowered Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE WE DEPENDING ON THE HOLY SPIRIT?
Central emphasis: Living in the power and presence of the Holy Spirit, receiving spiritual gifts, and participating in God's work beyond the limits of our natural capacities.
Christian discipleship is not simply a matter of personal effort and discipline. We depend upon the empowering presence of the Holy Spirit.
The Spirit distributes gifts for the building up of the body of Christ, not the glorification of particular individuals.
This stream reminds us that God's activity cannot be reduced to our strategies, programs, institutions, or political calculations.
Examples from Foster:
- Francis of Assisi (c. 1181–1226). Foster describes Francis's exuberant spiritual joy, worship, and spontaneous celebration. He uses Francis to illustrate the joyful vitality of life in the Spirit.
- William J. Seymour (1870–1922). The Black preacher associated with the 1906 Azusa Street Revival. Foster emphasizes Seymour's conviction that manifestations of the Spirit must produce greater love. The revival also created remarkable opportunities for worship and fellowship across racial and social divisions, although those gains were not always sustained.
Connection to public witness:
Faithful engagement requires more than intellectual sophistication, institutional power, or organizational capacity.
We need spiritual empowerment to love our enemies, persevere under pressure, remain hopeful amid discouragement, and bear witness to Christ when doing so is costly.
Seymour's example is particularly important: The evidence of the Spirit's work is not simply extraordinary power but extraordinary love.

Stream 4: The Social Justice Tradition — The Compassionate Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE WE PUTTING LOVE OF NEIGHBOR INTO PRACTICE?
Central emphasis: Expressing God's love through compassion, mercy, justice, and the pursuit of right relationships and social arrangements.
The gospel calls us beyond individual morality to concern for the well-being of our neighbors and the communities we inhabit.
Social justice in this tradition is not merely a political ideology. It emerges from the biblical witness concerning righteousness, mercy, and the dignity of human beings.
God's concern for justice includes both personal relationships and the structures that shape people's lives.
Examples from Foster:
- John Woolman (1720–1772). A Quaker whose Christian convictions led him to oppose slavery and challenge fellow Christians who participated in it. Foster highlights his combination of moral seriousness, persistent action, humility, and gentleness.
- Dorothy Day (1897–1980). Cofounder of the Catholic Worker movement, whose commitment to the poor combined direct acts of mercy with a critique of social injustice. Her spirituality translated into hospitality, service, and public action.
Connection to public witness:
This stream connects especially naturally with the AND Campaign's emphasis on compassion and justice.
But notice that the tradition does not allow us to separate how we fight for justice from the kind of people we become in the process.
Woolman's gentle confrontation of injustice is instructive. He did not confuse moral courage with personal hostility.

Stream 5: The Evangelical Tradition — The Word-Centered Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE OUR LIVES SHAPED BY THE WORD AND GOSPEL OF JESUS CHRIST?
Central emphasis: Commitment to Jesus Christ, the authority and teaching of Scripture, the proclamation of the gospel, and the invitation to conversion and discipleship.
The evangelical tradition emphasizes God's self-revelation and the transformative power of the gospel.
It insists that we must listen to the Word of God rather than merely baptize our existing assumptions.
It calls us not only to live in ways consistent with the gospel but also to proclaim its good news.
Examples from Foster:
- Augustine of Hippo (354–430). His conversion illustrates the power of Scripture and the gospel to reorient an individual's entire life.
- Billy Graham (1918–2018). Foster describes Graham's immersion in Scripture and lifelong commitment to proclaiming the gospel. His ministry illustrates the importance of bringing people to a personal response to Jesus Christ.
Connection to public witness:
Christians cannot simply acquire their political convictions from the prevailing ideologies of our culture and attach Christian language to them afterward.
The Word must have authority to challenge our political commitments, including the commitments of our preferred party, movement, or community.
The gospel also helps us maintain perspective. No political victory can replace the redemptive work of Jesus Christ.

Stream 6: The Incarnational Tradition — The Sacramental Life

KEY QUESTION: ARE WE RECOGNIZING AND SERVING GOD IN EVERY AREA OF LIFE?
Central emphasis: Experiencing and expressing God's presence in ordinary material existence—our work, relationships, bodies, homes, communities, and daily responsibilities.
The Incarnation teaches us that the material world is not inconsequential to the spiritual life.
This tradition resists the assumption that certain activities are inherently sacred while others are merely secular.
It invites us to bring the whole of our lives under the lordship of Jesus Christ.
Examples from Foster:
- Susanna Wesley (1669–1742). Foster presents her as an example of Christian devotion practiced amid the practical responsibilities and difficulties of family life. She did not need to escape ordinary life to practice genuine spirituality.
- Dag Hammarskjöld (1905–1961). The former UN Secretary-General exemplified an integration of contemplative faith and demanding public responsibilities. Foster uses him to illustrate spirituality lived through public vocation.
Connection to public witness:
This tradition is particularly helpful for understanding civic vocation.
We do not cease to be disciples when we enter a school board meeting, a legislative office, a courtroom, or a political conversation.
Those settings become places in which our discipleship must find concrete expression.

Bringing the Streams Together: A Robust Christian Spirituality

The danger isn't simply that some Christians are more contemplative while others are more charismatic or justice-oriented. Diversity of spiritual emphasis can be a gift.
The danger is allowing one genuine dimension of Christian spirituality to become a substitute for the whole.
When we emphasize only… We risk developing…
Contemplation A spirituality disconnected from the needs of our neighbors
Holiness A moralism that lacks grace and mercy
Charismatic experience Power without sufficient discernment and character
Social justice Activism without a sustaining spiritual center
Evangelical proclamation A faith that communicates truth without adequately embodying it
Incarnational practice A Christianity overly accommodated to the world

Jesus is not one example among six. He is the standard by which every stream must be measured.

Contemplative: Jesus regularly withdrew to pray (Luke 5:16).
Holiness: Jesus lived in complete obedience to the Father (John 8:29).
Charismatic: Jesus ministered in the power of the Holy Spirit (Luke 4:14–18).
Social Justice: Jesus proclaimed good news to the poor, confronted oppression, and embodied mercy (Luke 4:18–19).
Evangelical: Jesus proclaimed the kingdom and called people to repentance and faith (Mark 1:14–15).
Incarnational: Jesus, the Word made flesh, entered fully into human life (John 1:14).

These dimensions were not competing identities in Jesus. They formed a coherent life of communion with the Father, empowered by the Spirit, directed toward the Father's purposes.

The Four Domains of a Life

Private Domains:

Internal (Your Inner Life with God) - The hidden part of our spiritual life: prayer, Scripture meditation, self-reflection, personal repentance.
Intimate (Close Relationships – Family, Friends, Mentors) - The people who see our real character and influence our daily lives.

Public Domains:

Community (Your Intentional Connections – Church, Work, Groups) - Our committed communities where we serve, grow, and disciple one another.
Civic/Societal (Your Testimony Before the World – Strangers, Social Media, Society) - The outermost layer—our witness to those who don’t know us personally.

The AND Campaign insists that Christians must resist the false choice between compassion and conviction. But we cannot simply demand that Christians hold these two values together.

We have to cultivate the kind of spiritual lives that make such a witness possible.
A fragmented spirituality will eventually produce a fragmented public witness.
DISCUSS PRACTICES
Related Media
See more
Related Sermons
See more
Earn an accredited degree from Redemption Seminary with Logos.