What Can Restrain the Lord?
WHAT RESTRAINS THE LORD?
Jonathan’s plan for fighting the Philistines defied all military logic. First, he would give up the element of surprise: “We will cross over toward the men and let them see us” (v. 8). Second, he would avoid a skirmish with the Philistines if they abandoned their position of strategic superiority on the hilltop and exhausted themselves coming down to his position. On the other hand, he would attack if they challenged him to scale the sheer rock wall and then take them on. The plan is so absurd that if it did succeed it could only be because “the LORD has given them into our hands” (v. 10). Jonathan may have intended the phrase “the LORD has given them” as a wordplay on his own name, since it was expressed with a form of ntn and yhwh, the two lexical roots comprising his name.
Jonathan was not foolhardy, however, but allowed for the possibility of a mistake on his part. The way the Philistines responded to their approach would be taken as a sign from the Lord: a challenge to Come up would indicate potential victory.