Should I Obey the Government?
We are better citizens when we are heavenly citizens first.
I. A Christian’s Duty towards Skeptics (vv. 14-15)
The Pharisees, however, considered the Herod clan to be the evil usurpers of the throne of David; for, after all, Herod was an Edomite and not a Jew. The Pharisees also opposed the poll tax that the Romans had inflicted on Judea, and they resented the very presence of Rome in their land.
The actual taxes imposed were three.
(i) A ground tax, which consisted of one-tenth of all the grain and one-fifth of the wine and fruit produced. This was paid partly in kind and partly in money.
(ii) An income tax which amounted to one per cent of a man’s income.
(iii) A poll tax, which was levied on all men from fourteen to sixty-five and on all women from twelve to sixty-five. This poll tax was one denarius, roughly 3½p per head. It was the tax which everyone had to pay simply for the privilege of existing.
Yes’ would alienate Jewish patriots, who would see it as a pro-Roman answer; ‘No’ would provide a basis for denouncing Jesus to the provincial authorities as a rebel (Lk. 20:20 makes this last point explicit).
II. A Christian’s Duty to the Government (vv. 15-16)
The only coin that was accepted for payment of taxes in Judea, as throughout imperial territory, was the Roman denarius. This was a small silver coin that was worth normally about eighteen cents. The denarius of Tiberius portrayed the emperor as the semi-divine son of the god Augustus and the goddess Livia and bore the (abbreviated) inscription “Tiberius Caesar Augustus, Son of the Divine Augustus” on the obverse and “Pontifex Maximus” on the reverse. Both the representations and the inscriptions were rooted in the imperial cult and constituted a claim to divine honors.
It is beyond question that the Roman government brought to the ancient world a sense of security it never had before. For the most part, except in certain notorious areas, the seas were cleared of pirates and the roads of brigands, civil wars were changed for peace and capricious tyranny for Roman impartial justice. As E. J. Goodspeed wrote, “It was the glory of the Roman Empire that it brought peace to a troubled world. Under its sway the regions of Asia Minor and the East enjoyed tranquillity and security to an extent and for a length of time unknown before and probably since. This was the pax Romana. The provincial, under Roman sway, found himself in a position to conduct his business, provide for his family, send his letters, and make his journeys in security, thanks to the strong hand of Rome.”
Our Lord’s word is apodidōmi (ἀποδιδωμι) which speaks of paying something as a debt.
III. A Christian’s Duty towards God (v. 17)
The second part of his response, seen in the total context of Jesus’ life and teaching, shows that the duties toward God and Caesar, though distinct, are not completely separate, but are united and ruled by the higher principle of accomplishing in all things the will of God.
You give to Caesar only money. But to God, give yourself.