What is Wesleyan Arminianism
Preliminary & Review
Arminianism as such, in its broadest sense, is simply non-Augustinianism or non-Calvinism. It has many variations, “from the evangelical views of Arminius himself to left-wing liberalism.”1 What holds them all together is the rejection of the Augustinian concept of true total depravity (bondage of the will), and a belief in significant free will, at least in relation to the ability to accept or reject the gospel offer of salvation.
It is actually a misnomer to call this view “Arminianism” since it existed long before James Arminius (A.D. 1560–1609). It was the consensus belief in Christendom prior to Augustine (A.D. 354–430),2 and was affirmed by even Augustine, especially but not exclusively in his earlier years.3 For example, Augustine declared in A.D. 412 that the Creator gave human beings free will as “an intermediate power, which is able either to incline towards faith, or to turn towards unbelief.… God no doubt wishes all men to be saved, but yet not so as to take away from them their liberty of will.”4 Catholic thinking in the Middle Ages was mixed but from the time of the Reformation,5 official Roman Catholic teaching has been in line with Arminianism.6 In the sixteenth century the Anabaptists and most of the Radical Reformation taught a doctrine of (restored) free will, contrary to the main Reformers.7