Al Moehler, The Briefing, Tuesday, Nov 23, 2021 - It had to be an absolutely harrowing site. The crowd was gathered for a Christmas festival on Sunday night, when an SUV pressed into the crowd. We're told the bodies flew through the air. Eventually, almost 50 people were injured. At least five had died in Waukesha, Wisconsin. And the harrowing site was actually something that brings the biggest of moral issues to mind. It raises massive questions because SUVs are not supposed to hurdle themselves into a crowd gathered for a Christmas festival. People were there for a parade. People were there in order to begin the Christmas season. People were there in order to enjoy the fellowship and the fun. But of course, this wasn't merely a vehicle that went into the crowd, killing five, at least five thus far, and injuring almost 50.
It was a human being behind the wheel with every indication of having done so deliberately. Now, as you think about this, you recognize the inadequacy of a secular worldview, trying to answer the question. But at the same time you see that worldview or those who are operating out of that worldview, trying to get to the biggest question. The biggest question of course is, why? Why would anyone have done this? Now, here's something to watch. Our first thought has to be for the people there in Wisconsin who are grieving and those whose lives are right now critically on the line. We pray for those individuals. We pray for their families. We pray for a grieving community. But you also notice that even as this a crime that has taken place, people immediately wanted to know what does the crime mean? What would've been the motivation behind it?
What was the motive? Why would anyone do this? Now, one of the things we need to note is that in our contemporary context, driven primarily by a secular worldview, the options are pretty limited to come up with explanations of why. For one thing, you really can't deal much with the idea of inherent evil. Instead, you have to look for some other explanation. There must be some sociological explanation. You see this playing out in so many public debates. Perhaps there's a political or an economic motivation. Given the worldwide context of terrorism, people began to ask the question, rather automatically, was this a terrorist attack? Was it personal? That's another interesting question. Was it personal? Was this an effort to try to bring about homicide or injury to specific individuals against which the driver was aggrieved? By the time, yesterday evening came to a conclusion, it was pretty clear that police were not ready to say this was a terrorist activity.
There was no sign, at least as of last night, that there was any kind of organized ideology behind this. There was no link to any kind of terrorist network. When it comes to the understanding that it might have been personal, law enforcement officials there in Wisconsin have at least dismissed that, initially as a reality. Instead, there is this effort to try to come up with some explanation that would make evil rational, that would make this irrational attack explainable in rational terms. Now, here's where Christians understand, that there are limits to how rational irrationality can be. When we think about evil, we need to understand that the Christian worldview presents evil in a multifaceted way. It is first of all, a rebellion or a revolt against God. Now, in that sense, very importantly, evil predates creation, because the fall of Satan and his fallen angels came before the creation of the world. Evil thus as rebellion against God already existed.
And God given his sovereignty, his omnipotence, and his glory, his justice and his righteousness, even before the creation of the world, God was determined that he would bring evil to an end. That's very clear in the revelation of God's own character and power. But then of course came the creation of the world. And shortly, after the creation of human beings made in God's image, we sinned. That's right. The scripture says that Adam and Eve sinned, but the Scripture also says that "In Adam we sinned." Let's try to come up with a rational explanation for the fall. In reality, it simply can't be explained in rational terms at all. Rationally, Adam should never have sinned against God. Rationally, Adam should never have yielded to temptation. Rationally, Adam should have looked at the entire creation along with Eve and understood it to be good and given to us for our enjoyment in the garden.
But there was that one tree and that one tree became an irrational obsession. After the fall, evil has become an inescapable part of human experience. Not just in the world out there, not just in the headlines, not just in a murderous street in Wisconsin, but in our own experience and in our own lives. Indeed, the scripture says "In our own hearts." And this means that even within ourselves, evil has a rational expression, but it has irrational roots. We cannot explain even with satisfaction to ourselves why we see ourselves fall short of our own expectations. That's the kind of testimony we see from the apostle Paul in Romans 7. The biblical balance between the rational and the irrational is seen in the fact that the police already seemed to have calculated, come to the conclusion in their investigation, that the man who is now the central suspect, a man known as Darrell Brooks Jr, had a pattern of criminal activity.
The mainstream media have reported that he was at least arrested more than 10 times since 1999 on criminal charges. Furthermore, there were at least two open criminal charges and someone in the District Attorney's office there in Wisconsin, indicated that he was free because prosecutors had asked for an unacceptably low bail. The Associated Press reported yesterday, "The man suspected of plowing his SUV into a Christmas parade in suburban Milwaukee, killing at least five people and injuring 48, had left the scene of a domestic dispute just minutes before." The police there in Wisconsin have now drawn up five charges of intentional homicide against the man who's identified as a 39 year old citizen of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. As the story unfolded, the team of the Associated Press reported, "A joyous scene of marching bands and children dancing in Santa hats and waving pompoms gave way in an instant to screams and the sight of crumpled bodies as the SUV sped through barricades and struck dancers, musicians, and others. Members of a Dancing Grannies club were among those killed, as was an employee of Citizen's Bank."
Here's the rational and the irrational dimension that is so central to the biblical worldview. This man, we are likely to discover, had at least some rational plan, some rational motivation to conduct evil. He used his reason. He used his intelligence. He used his bodily presence. He used an SUV in order to carry out intentional homicide. But at the same time you asked the question, why? There is not going to be an acceptable secular answer. Psychology can get you, only so far. Criminology, only so far, sociology, politics, economics, only so far. Even genetics. People are trying to look for some genetic or biological basis for all kinds of things. But in reality, the secular worldview simply doesn't have the equipment to answer the question about the absurdity of sin. What we see here is the darkness of the human heart. And we know, in biblical terms and in contemporary terms, even if we're honest, in personal terms, just how dark that can be.
Just how irrational, just how inexplicable, just how contrary to our own good. But the allure of evil is one of the earliest truths we learn in scripture. We will continue to follow this story. We will continue to pray for the people in Wisconsin. We will continue to think of those families who have suffered such utterly inexplicable and horrifying loss. It's also just not wrong to want to know more, to want to know why, but in reality let's just face this up front. There will never be, in secular terms, an adequate satisfactory answer to the question why.