Experiences of God
Introduction
Karl Barth’s Two Perplexities
The people do not need us to help them with the appurtenances of their daily life. They look after those things without advice from us and with more wisdom than we usually credit them with. But they are aware that their daily life and all the questions which are factors in it are affected by a great What? Why? Whence? Whither? which stands like a minus sign before the whole parenthesis and changes to a new question all the questions inside—even those which may already have been answered. They have no answer for this question of questions, but are naive enough to assume that others may have. So they thrust us into our anomalous profession and put us into their pulpits and professorial chairs, that we may tell them about God and give them the answer to their ultimate question. Why do they not themselves seek to master it, as they have sought to master everything else? Why do they come to us, when they must long since have made the discovery that they cannot expect the same service from us as they do from an attorney or a dentist, for instance, and that if the truth must be told we can answer their question no better than they themselves? One may well ask. Their coming gives evidence not so much of their hope for an answer from us as of their inability, shared with all mankind, to answer their question themselves.
However this may be, we are asked the question; and we ought to understand what the people have in mind when they ask it. It is evident that they do not need us to help them live, but seem rather to need us to help them die; for their whole life is lived in the shadow of death.