The Mysterious Stranger
A Time of Contemplation
As they walked, they conversed about the recent events and discussed what they might mean. They did the best they could with the limited knowledge they had, but they lacked the key that would unlock the prophetic Scriptures: the Messiah must suffer and die before He could enter into His glory. It was this key that Jesus provided as He walked and talked with them on the road.
A Time of Confusion
These two men were “slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken” (v. 25, paraphrase mine). They believed the promises about Messiah’s glory, but they could not accept the prophecies about His suffering (1 Peter 1:8–12).
A Time of Confirmation
Luke 24:27
Interpreted (διηρμηνευσεν [diērmēneusen]). First aorist active (constative aorist) indicative of διερμηνευω [diermēneuō] (Margin has the imperfect διηρμηνευεν [diērmēneuen]), intensive compound (δια [dia]) of ἑρμηνευω [hermēneuō], the old verb to interpret from ἑρμηνευς [hermēneus], interpreter, and that from ἑρμης [Hermēs], the messenger of the gods as the people of Lystra took Paul to be (Acts 14:12). But what wonderful exegesis the two disciples were now hearing! Concerning himself (περι ἑαυτον [peri heauton]). Jesus found himself in the Old Testament, a thing that some modern scholars do not seem able to do.
How we know the Resurrection is historical and not an invented story:
(1) It presents the first resurrection appearance as happening to two otherwise unknown, non-apostolic Christians, but
(2) it names one of them
(3) The appearance was less than spectacular or immediately convincing
(4) The wealth of detail (such as the location of Emmaus) is not consistent with a story invented to prove the resurrection but is in keeping with an eyewitness account (Lk 1:2).
28:17 All the resurrection narratives record the doubt of some of the characters at one point or another. The early church preserved in its tradition the fact that the apostles were not expecting the resurrection, despite repeated predictions of it by Jesus Himself. This can only be a historical reminiscence, and it corroborates the disciples’ later faith in the resurrection. That is, the actual appearance of the resurrected Jesus best accounts for the historical facts that the disciples initially did not believe Christ had risen and that they later were convinced He had.
A Time of Celebration
A Time of Confidence
Luke 24:35
Rehearsed (ἐξηγουντο [exēgounto]). Imperfect middle indicative of ἐξηγεομαι [exēgeomai], verb to lead out, to rehearse. Our word exegesis comes from this verb. Their story was now confirmatory, not revolutionary. The women were right then after all. Of them (αὐτοις [autois]). To them, dative case. They did not recognize Jesus in his exegesis, but did in the breaking of bread. One is reminded of that saying in the Logia of Jesus: “Raise the stone and there thou shalt find me, cleave the wood and there am I.”
There is a pattern of events. The history of Israel has always moved from despair to hope, from slavery to exodus, from exile to return. Surely the experience of the Messiah will be the same—from death to resurrection. But at Passover? Of course!